December 22, 2020

The Cannata Chronicles

Welcome to the Cannata Clan!


This is the greatest picture in Cannata family history. It was taken during a party at my sister Rosie's house during the 1970's. There are 12 of the 15 Cannata siblings in the picture. Having that many of my brothers and sisters in one place at one time almost never happened. It means the beer must have been free.

The stories here recount some of the best legends and lies I have spun about my life growing up in the middle of a ridiculously huge family. With a mix of facts and fables and family historians I have chronicled my formative years in seriously embellished stories 

I hope you enjoy them. Let me know if you have any questions about any of my siblings or if you would like to know more.

December 21, 2020

The Worst of Worship

Like most children I was indoctrinated into the Catholic religion by my parents before I could formerly object. Not being able speak I was unable to express my opinion one way or the other. I was baptized and made to attend Mass under duress, I attended Sunday school and confession on a weekly basis. I resisted every effort to assimilate me. 

When I was given a copy of the bible I did what I thought they expected… something I found out later that most people have never done… I actually read it. The difference being, unlike most people, I never for a minute bought into the story of god.

The Bible’s stories were interesting, but obviously fictional. When I started asking questions the nuns gave me answers that I found lacking. They in turn got angry when I explained I still didn’t understand. They began to get angrier with each question when I expressed doubt at the answers. My questions seemed reasonable to me.

For instance, if Jesus was the “only begotten son of God”, who were the “Sons of God” referred to in Genesis? If God created man on the sixth day then why is Adam considered the “First” man God created? If Adam and Eve were the first people where did the people in city of Lot come from?  Where did Cain and Able get their wives and why aren’t their names mentioned? And these were just the questions from the first chapter.

It was clear that the priests and nuns considered me annoying and my persistent questions demonstrated disrespect bordering on blasphemy. Their answers were suspect and I had plenty of doubt. Unable to give a rational reply they explained it would make God happy if I would just take their word on it. I should trust them, have faith and just believe in God and his mercy. Some things it seemed only God could know.

As soon as possible I quit going to church and put as much distance between any religion and myself as I could. I do not and have never believed in God. Religion and its seriousness is something that scares me. Sitting in church, watching the herd of worshipers go through their rote and ritual has always made me feel creepy. To this day I will not enter a church, pray, participate in or support any event based on or promoted by religious organizations.

To most people that qualifies me as an atheist. But that’s not how I think of myself. Once it was clear that the story of God and how he created the universe wasn’t the truth the question for me became what is true? While I don’t believe in the story of creation, I also don’t believe totally in the theory of evolution. So if neither one of those stories is true, what is the truth?

While I don’t know what the truth is I know one thing for sure… it isn’t going to be found in religion. At the root of every religion is a God that is as vengeful, evil and cruel as any man he created. His only superiority to men is his capacity for destruction. God has the ability to destroy everyone on earth at anytime, for any reason. And he has more than once. He doesn’t have to answer to anyone for it either. Floods, plagues, fire and brimstone, when it comes to laying waste to all his children, he can use what ever means handy. He may be bigger, greater, wiser and stronger, but he sure isn’t kinder or gentler.

Sadly, his followers aren’t any different. Every devout religious group seems hell bent on destroying some other equally devout group.  And God is the guy they’re doing it for. As soon as we knew that God loved us we also knew who he hated. He hated everyone that we hated. More people have been slaughtered in God’s name than all other causes put together.

Nowhere is this conflict in religious beliefs more evident than in the events of 9/11. The world has been filled with religious strife long before that date.  Yet, it seems that since September 11th my senses have been assaulted almost daily by some of the most horrible acts of violence and debauchery that children of Gwqeeeeeeeeeeeeeefod are guilty of.  Crimes of holy vengeance committed in the course of worship, done in the name of God and with his blessing.

Christians, Jews, Muslims and other children of God were sacrificed on the bloody alter of religious hatred. Depending on your point of view God was either horrified or delighted by the acts that were committed in his name that day. No human being in his right mind could see the destruction and react with anything other than total and complete moral outrage.

Unless it was something God wanted you to do.

Whether you believe as they did or not, the terrorists believed that God wanted them to do what they did.  It was holy, devout and god loving men flying those planes on 9/11. They were reverent and righteous and true believers in the word of Allah. Faithful, zealous believers who were acting as their faith and their religion demanded. They believed sincerely that God loved them and blessed them for it all. When the terrorists flew the planes into the World Trade Center they believed Allah himself was the one doing the flying and they were singing his praises all the way. They were men of God doing God’s biding and God was on their side all the way. And they were absolutely correct.

Of course, from a different perspective things look quite different

The people in the towers were also good, decent, caring, god-fearing human beings no different than the guys flying the planes... except for their religious leanings. They were children of God as well. As they were fleeing the towers they were all praying to God asking for his help in saving their lives. One by one, as they made it to safety the survivors thanked God for saving them. It was a miracle from God that they were alive. They were blessed by God. God was on their side all the way. And they were absolutely correct.

Of course, again, from a different perspective, they could both be wrong.

The survivors might think God saved them but ask the terrorist and it’s a different story.  From his view, God didn’t save them. He missed them. Allah was clearly on the terrorist’s side if you are on the Martyrs side of the stadium. He personally helped steer those planes right into the holy target and slaughtered the infidels. The holy martyrs believe God truly was an excellent co- pilot.

For the survivors, as far as they’re concerned, God was responsible for saving all those that were lucky enough to escape. The survivors know, without any reservation, God was their holy savior.

Unfortunately, no matter what side you’re on or what you want to believe about God, there is one thing that is certain. Almost four thousand people died that day at the hands of men; Fervent and reverent men, acting as the Hand of God. God may have been with the Muslims or with the infidels. He may have shielded as many of his children as possible from the hate of the zealots. But who God favored or why doesn’t change that one horrible truth. For all his children who died that day God didn’t do squat. They have had the chance to see whether their heaven is real. As though for some reason they were expendable. Perhaps, being of little faith either way, they were sacrificed for their indifference. Ion my opinion, this makes God a poor father to his children.

Think what you want. You might believe beyond doubt that the terrorists were madmen and God will see that they burn in hell for what they did. And you might be right.

But the martyrs believed just as passionately that God was with them. They bid his bidding and they will reap their reward as martyrs in a blissful heaven. And they might be right too.

But that’s the nature of faith. Unless you know something that the rest of the world doesn’t your beliefs are no more credible or correct than theirs. The only one that does know is God and he ain’t talking.

I don’t believe God exists, but I could be wrong. Regardless of what they call him all religions seem to agree that there is only one God. If that’s true, it seems reasonable to assume that if there is One God then there must be One Truth;

One or none… we each don’t get to pick and choose between the two.

If there is a God then the question becomes whose side is he on? When it comes to help from God the survivors and the terrorists can’t both be right when they say God was helping them can they? The terrorists believe! The survivors believe. All mankind’s religions believe they know what God wants.

But there is a big difference between believing and knowing. And when it comes to knowing for certain, if God is real then he’s the only one who does..

 

April 30, 2020

Chapter 22 - Families and Felons

Families and Felons

I was a pretty good kid all in all growing up. Everybody said I was a pretty smart kid. Smart as I was I did make my share of stupid mistakes. I learned about the perils of a life of crime in a way that made me realize once again… never admit you are a Cannata to a stranger unless it’s a matter of life or death. Even then you should think carefully because circumstances sometimes are that being dead would be the better option. Because, as the kid that gave me my first serious punch in the nose told me… “Cannatas Suck!”
There was a business in my neighborhood by the name of the “Forest Hills Factory Outlet.” Not that I knew of any factory that was in Jamaica Plain that manufactured the goods sold there. It was big by neighborhood standards and it was a great place to go and hang around and buy popcorn and little gifts around Christmas or a sibling’s birthday.
It was also where I made one of my earliest and misguided forays into a life of crime; Shoplifting to be exact. What I lifted from the store wasn’t very memorable. It was a cheesy little bike lock that didn’t cost more than five bucks. In fact I still have no idea what it was that enticed me to try and purloin it from the store to begin with. But since everything in the store was as cheaply made as possible, and cost about $10.00 max. It didn’t exactly amount grand larceny.
Yet, by the time the adventure was over, I had been handcuffed, hauled off to the local police station… the infamous station 13… and compared to some hideous member of a national crime syndicate. I was accused of being a central figure of a vicious, insidious criminal organization that was headed by my father and supported by almost all the members of my felonious family.
I can’t recall much about the circumstances behind my apprehension, but what happened once I got to the station is forever imbedded in my memory. It was an event that once again demonstrated that no matter how well I thought I knew my family and who they were… I really didn’t know the half of them. And let me tell you, finding out that your father and oldest brother are well heeled criminals involved in car theft; racketeering and toilet papering for no good reason other than to wreak havoc on the innocent people of Jamaica Plain can be pretty disturbing.
I thought my father was a post office worker. Incredibly, according to the cop that revealed all the dirty secrets, he was just short of an insane hitman. And my brother Joe was his henchman extraordinaire. Together they made a team of nefarious hoodlums hell-bent on taking over the entire neighborhood of Jamaica Plain.
It all started once I was handcuffed, chained and manacled to a chair at station 13. That’s where they put dangerous aspiring criminals of about eight or nine years old while they waited for their parents to come, collect then and take them home for the beating of their lives. One I’m sure they would have preferred to deliver themselves, but in those days cops didn’t really feel threatened much by elementary school villains. We also had to stay locked to the chair because we were still small enough to slip thru the bars that lined the cells in the basement and escape was always a possibility for shrewd and clever little felons such as me.
As I sat waiting, one rather large cop sauntered up to me and gave me a piercing look. One that said he had my number and I’d better fess up to what he was about to say or face some serious consequences.
“So”. He said. “You’re a Cannata, eh?”
Since I had already admitted to that, despite my tendency to deny it almost every chance I had it seemed silly to try and change it now. “Yeah” I muttered. Head down and ready to put on my best imitation of a chagrined and remorseful delinquent.
“So,” he says again. “Do you know Johnny Cannata?”
“Yeah” I said again. My father’s name was. John. Although I never recalled anyone in my house ever calling him Johnny to his face, we all knew his name. Even if we were pretty sure my Dad didn’t know half of his kid’s names.
“What about Joey Cannata? You know him too don’t ya?” He seemed to be trying to catch me in some sort of lie but I wasn’t falling for it.
“Yeah,” I replied.
“I’m sure you do! You hang around with them don’t ya?!” He stated this in a tone that seemed to accuse me of something that wasn’t yet clear.
I wasn’t quite sure how to respond because even though I and my brother Joe and my dad lived in the same house, I wouldn’t exactly describe our relationship as one where we “hung out” with each other. My brother Joe was many years older than me and didn’t spend a heck of a lot of his time playing with me, although it might have been fun. And I spent most of the time my dad was home doing my best to avoid him. He wasn’t the kind of dad that liked to interact with his kids any more than necessary.
So I gave a vague and non-committal answer, “Yeah, sort of.”
“You like those guys huh?” He growled.
“Most of the time,” I said. It was a truthful answer and pretty accurate.
“Well you know what I think?” He said as he got closer to my face with a snarl.
I had no idea what he thought but my impression was that it wasn’t going to be something good. Before I could venture a guess he told me just what he thought about Johnny and Joey Cannata.
“I think they SUCK!!” he shouted as he poked a finger in my chest. “Those guys are nothing but trouble! And I think you’re gonna wind up just like ‘em!”
The finger in my chest kind of hurt but it wasn’t nearly as bad as the look on his face. Obviously this cop did not like my dad or my brother. He went on to explain just why and I have to say, it was not what I expected at all.
“Johnny and Joey Cannata are nothing but punks!  Troublemakers! They’re heading for big trouble and when I finally get a hold of them they are going away for a long, long time!”
Afraid to speak, all I could do was let my mind take in his accusations. My dad and my brother Joe were criminals?? This was news to me! I heard a lot of stories about how mean my father could be and he was prone to threatening us with “The Belt” on occasion. But he had never actually hit anyone with it as far as I knew. My brother Joe was a soldier and I knew he knew how to blow things up, but he never tried to destroy anything in our house.
I made a meek effort to come to their defense.  I used one of my patented responses that seemed to fit. “They din’t do nothin’!”
“What??” he shouted angrily! “Those two guys are in and out of here all the time. We just had that bum Johnny locked up here last weekend!! He was drunk as a bowery boy and was caught trying to steal a car! I bet you think that is pretty cool huh?”
I didn’t think it was “cool” at all. In fact it was kind of confusing. My dad already had a car. A new one too that was only eight years old. Why would he steal another one? This was getting stranger by the minute. I was doing my best to look calm but the chair I was in was slowly making its way around the room as I sat shaking in it.
“That lowlife, Johnny, is gonna end up in the slammer and Joey won’t be far behind him. I’ve seen kids just like ‘em a hundred times and they always end up the same. Looks to me like you’re gonna go the same way, unless, of course, you smarten up. I swear, the next time I see that Johnny I’m gonna smack him good!””
Now I was about as confused as ever. My dad was a lot of things but a “kid” he was not. Even worse, my dad was coming to get me and this cop was threatening to smack my dad. One thing for sure, for every smack the cop gave my dad I was gonna get two from my dad myself. The time had come for me to start defending my dad and let this cop know I wasn’t going to stand by while he laid a beating on my father no matter how much a criminal he was.
“You better not touch him you asshole! If you do you’re gonna be very sorry.” My threat might have sounded a lot more serious if I wasn’t hand-cuffed to a chair and at least 3 feet shorter but I did my best to look as serious as possible. The look on the cops face was something I’ll never forget. One half horrified and one half hilarious. He seemed about to laugh and give me a serious slap when the door opened and another cop announced my father’s arrival. I was prepared to watch my dad and this cop go to battle
To my shock and surprise the cop turned and shook my father’s hand and greeted him with a friendly hello
“How are you, Mr. Cannata?” he asked. “I’m sorry to have to make you come here but we had a problem with, Michael here. We didn’t want to get formal so I thought you’d like to come by and deal with this yourself.”
“Thanks, Charlie. I appreciate you giving me first crack at him,” my dad said as he gave me a stare that suggested the worst was yet to come. With that he and the cop walked up front and exchanged some words that had them both smiling. I was completely befuddled at this point. This cop was yukking it up with my dad. The guy he had just finished referring to as the second coming of Al Capone!
When he took the handcuffs off he whispered quietly, “Remember what I said kid. You don’t want to wind up like Johnny or Joey, you hear?”
Giving me a stern look my dad took me by the shoulder and escorted me to the car. “We’ll talk about this when we get home. I’m very disappointed in you, Michael.” He growled.
I couldn’t believe it! He was disappointed in me? I just found out that he and Joe were a mini mafia! All I did was steal a bike lock. I exploded in a rant of confession and confusion.. I told him everything the cop had accused him and my brother Joe of doing and all the names he called them.
As I finished my story and looked at him he had that really creepy look that passed as a smile. A look I rarely saw. Clearly, he found something funny about what I told him.
“Have I ever mentioned that you have two juvenile delinquent cousins by the names of Johnny and Joey on Mission Hill? No? Well that’s another thing we’ll talk about when we get home.”
When the talk, the lecture and the small but well targeted smacks were done, I sat in my room and once again realized it was true…
… Cannatas Suck!

April 20, 2019

Chapter 21 - The Star Man

The Star Man Waiting for Me.



I have a lot of brothers. To be honest, more than any human being really needs. There was a brother of every kind, shape and size for me to choose from as the situation demanded. There was the older, bigger brother you feared and pretty much avoided when he was in a bad mood. The one that helped keep a lot of bullies away from you by reputation. 

There was the brother closest to me that I had a rivalry with. Always debating about who was the smartest or the best looking. Seriously speaking, there never was any rivalry because it was obvious that I was by far the smartest and best looking, Yet, to allow them to entertain their sibling fantasy I indulged them in their fantasy when it came to thinking they had a chance. 

I had older brothers and younger ones, fatter and skinnier ones.. I loved them all as best I could. I sort of had to. They were my brothers and that's what you did with the family you are given.  Above all, without question, there was one brother that was by far my favorite.

Bobby, formally known as Robert, was the brother I liked the most. I loved, Bobby, with all my heart. While all my siblings had a place and enhanced my life in  many ways, there were so many things that Bobby and I shared that made him extra special.

He was the most accommodating person I ever knew. He would do all he could to help anyone he met. And since we lived together we met quite often. He never refused me a favor when I needed it. That's what I remember best about my little brother, Bobby. Once he could walk and carry a note I could count on Bobby tor un errands for me when I was sick or just too damn lazy to go myself. 

He was always willing to go to the store and get me a soda and my favorite comic on a Saturday morning while making a buck. The truth is he would go for me whether I had a buck to give him or not.  He went anywhere anytime for me whenever I asked. It was just the first of many ways he would help me throughout my life.

He had another special talent that made him unique and one of the most important people nearest to my own heart. He could make seriously good popcorn. He was the only other person I could trust to make popcorn just the way I did. Believe me, there is nothing as special as enjoying a bowl of fresh popped, buttered popcorn.

Don't misunderstand, I loved all my brothers and we all had a lot of fun together. Unlike a lot of my other brothers, though, when it came to the need for it, Bobby could always be counted on to provide great company. He guaranteed there would always be someone cool to hang out with. He would walk with me or just hang out and listen to my insane dissertations about life and all that mattered to me with the sort of interest that never seemed feigned.

He would ask serious questions and sit quietly as I gave him an answer that took an hour and several attempts to revise them to the point where they made sense to me.  He always replied in a way that never insulted me no matter how crazy the topic was. We had great fun together no matter what else was going on.

He grew up to be a big strong guy who had a heart as big as he was. He was as blue collar as a man comes. Bobby was one of the most dependable and reliable people on earth He could be counted on… always. He was the source of a  man who would provide a jump start and bail money personified. 

Whenever I, or any of his brothers, experienced one of those routine disasters that often struck, we knew we could count on Bobby for help.  Day or night, rain or shine, drunk or sober, he would always answer the phone. He was always ready to help. You could depend on him. If Bob said he'd be there, it was settled. I would trust him with my life, my children and my dog without a thought.

And believe me, my dog, Tara, was my most precious companion. Bobby was the only person Tara would ever trust her life with other than me. Because, Bobby was a dog man.
Like me, he had a great love for dogs. I adopted a beautiful German Shepard dog from the, Angell Memorial Animal Hospital, when I was 21. She was about a year old, very timid and fearful of people. It took a while to get her to trust me, but once she did she never left my side unless I left her in the house to go out. She didn't trust anyone else, even going so far as to take a small bite at my father and best friend when they raised their voice or hands towards me.

The only other person Tara loved and would always greet with a wagging tail and slurping tongue was Bobby. If I wasn't around she would stick to Bobby like glue. I had her for 12 years and it was like that for her entire life. Bobby and I were her world.

Sometime after Tara was gone Bobby got himself another German Shepard dog. He was a huge, powerful beast that would strike fear into the heart of most normal people. Yet, where most people heard a huge threatening roar when they approached Bobby's house, I always heard the happy greeting of a massive, over grown puppy that never quite learned how to play fetch. Kaiser loved me almost as much as he did, Bobby.

In much the same way Bobby shared my bond with Tara, I was the only other person that Kaiser seemed to greet with unbridled enthusiasm. He would greet me at the door and throw his 150lb frame at me as though I could catch him like I did when he was a pup. Then he would insist that I come out and throw the nearest ball or stick for him.

           I would happily throw the object of his desire and he would run at full speed and pick it up and run back to me… and that was pretty much the end of our fetch game. It never occurred to Kaiser that he had to give me the ball back if he wanted me to throw it again. For the rest of my visit he would run around the yard, occasionally coming near enough to taunt me into trying to grab it from him. I would make a lunge which almost never succeeded and then Kaiser would run away again holding his prize tight in his jaws.

Along with our love of dogs, another thing we shared was our love, and need, for cars that actually worked. When it came to keeping our cars going, as far and as long as they could, no one was better than Bobby, Bobby was a car guy.

The connection between me and Bobby was never as obvious as it was when it came to our love of cars and driving. Well, actually, while we both loved driving, I hated cars. They always needed fixing, which required money, something I was always in short supply of. As luck would have it, I had something better than money, I had Bobby.

Bobby loved fixing cars just as much as driving them. He could fix everything and anything when it came to cars. He could use tools with exceptional skill and as a result he always had a working car. Most importantly he had what one needs the most when it came to repairing a car… he had tools…LOTS of tools.

We worked on cars a lot when he was in the Navy.  As a member of the motor pool we had access to an enormous garage with everything a do- it-yourself mechanic could ask for. For me, the best thing it had was Bobby.

Growing up, we bonded while working on our cars, trying to squeeze every mile out of a hundred dollar shitbox before abandoning it for scrap somewhere in New England. Between us, we left a car by the side of the road in every state in New England, New York and other nearby states. With Bobby's guidance, and his expert knowledge of cars, I was able to fix almost any problem; from changing spark plugs to changing entire engines and transmissions.  He taught me more than I ever wanted to know about repairing cars.

Both of us made our living as professional drivers. I drove a taxi for 15 years and various other vehicles for 20 more. Bob drove trucks. He was a long haul tractor trailer driver for many years. Over our lifetime together we drove all the routes and roads, highways and byways of New England.

And then there was, Grizzly Bob.

We spent many summer days and nights camping together with our kids in the White Mountains in New Hampshire. We discovered the "Crazy Horse" campground up around Bartlett, New Hampshire and it quickly became the place for many camping adventures with friends and family over the decades as our families grew older and, eventually, apart.

On our first visit to the campground, Bob showed me how a REAL man made a campfire. His method involved lots of damp wood and kindling, a quart or more of gasoline and a major risk to the lives of us, our kids and the nearby campsites. But let me tell you, once that 25 foot column of flame calmed down enough for us to re-enter our campsite, it was a seriously impressive fire.

We also moved a lot together. Another major resource that Bobby provided came in handy a lot more often than it ever should. Bobby could always get a truck. After leaving home and getting my first apartment I found that I had the need to move often. Staying ahead of evictions and overdue utility payments was one way I managed to keep a roof over my head. Bobby helped me move at least a dozen times.

Bobby did so much for me it would a take a book to tell all the stories that would bring him to life. But there was one very special thing he did that will always make him shine whenever I remember him. He gave me back something I thought had been lost forever to the dreary nights that can be a part of life in a big city.

This is the story of how Bobby gave me back the stars.

I have always loved looking at the stars on a clear night. When I was a kid you could still do that on a clear night on the outskirts of Boston. Today, the city's lights blank out almost any star. There seem to be times even the moon is too dim to see well through the neon blaze.

Bobby had a pretty nice telescope, but try as we could it was still hard to find a star, even with the built in star finder on the telescope. It led me to wonder where the hell all the stars went. It was Bobby who answered the question and gave me a thrill I will always remember. He suggested I take a ride with him and he would show me where all the stars went.

A week or so later, Bobby called and asked me to take a ride with him while he brought a load up to the top of Maine. It was a long ride with a quick turnaround and he wanted some company. Bob was always great company so I agreed.

We left the lights of eastern Massachusetts behind and traveled deeper into the dark and watched the daylight fade behind us.  After the night had taken over, at a particularly dark stretch of road somewhere in the middle of Maine, he pulled over to the side of the empty highway and shut down the truck. After I got out of the cab, still worried about getting run over, even though there wasn't a headlight to be seen for miles in either direction, he shut off all the lights on the truck and got out to join me.

It was as dark a night as I had ever experienced without any light at all around me other than the moon in the sky. I could say without shame or embarrassment, for a time, I was honestly afraid. It was the kind of darkness city people almost never experience. I could hear Bobby. But, even though he was only 10 feet away, I couldn't see him. Still, his voice was comforting and sounded almost delighted.

"Take a look at the sky now, Michael," he said to me.  As I gazed up I still couldn't make out a big difference between what I could see there from the sky I could see from Blue Hills lookout point. A solid point of light or two was all that stood out.

"Just keep looking," he said.

Slowly, as my eyes grew accustomed to the almost surreal darkness of the deep Maine woods, more stars seemed to spring out of the black sky. One by one, then in clusters and soon in great bursts of light filled with patches of stars, like glittering blotches of light in the sky.

We watched the Milky Way pass overhead. It looked like a giant paint brush had left a trail of thick lustrous stars from horizon to horizon. It moved slowly across the clearest summer night I can ever recall.

As we climbed back into the truck I could still see the patterns of the stars on the dark of my eyelids when I closed my eyes. Then he laughed and said "Now, I'll show you where the planets have fallen to the Earth."

Far along on Route 1, in Maine, in a little town called, Houlton, he pulled the truck over and pointed to the top of a pole next to the road. Even with his high powered spotlight to help, it was almost impossible to say what it was.

"That," Bob said, smiling "is Pluto."

I was to learn that it was the first model in something that was called, "The Maine Model Solar System." Spread along the highway between, Houlton, and Presque Isle, Maine, measured at a distance of about 1 "astronomical unit" per mile, were models of each planet in our solar system built to scale and mounted on the top of long poles. Bobby had fun slowing down as we approached each planet but he wouldn't tell me which pole… or even if there was a pole to mark the location. Finding the planets became a game that helped pass a lot of miles.

We counted down the planets as we passed them sitting on the side of a highway in Maine. As we approached the top of the world, the pinnacle of New England; our trip ended just a few miles from the Canadian border. That was where he dropped one container and picked up another for the trip back to Boston.

Leaving behind the sun that was rising over Presque Isle hours earlier than it did in Boston  we headed back home passing the planets again as we left the sun behind. It was a memory that still leaves stars in my eyes when I close them and remember our long dark ride together.

Bobby died in April of 2015. In just the few years since that trip with Bob I have lost three brothers and my son. Barely having the time to catch my breath and process each loss before the next one hit. When Bob passed away he took the stars with him.

I sit here now, four years later, still mourning Bob's passing and fear I will never breathe freely again. His loss has taken the wind from my sails; forever it seems. I feel so much more hopeless and helpless without him. I feel that, without him, I will never be able to fix anything again; starting with a heart that seems broken beyond repair.

My enormous family has always prevented me from ever really understanding what it would feel like to truly be alone. With an imagination that I always felt had no limit, being alone was something almost unimaginable to me.

I fear now, I can feel the concept creeping into the edge of my imagination. Being without Bobby, I'm pretty sure, mingled with the grief, lurks a very sure sense of what it must feel like to finally be alone.

Ours was the longest goodbye. It took years for his illness to take him. I missed him before he was even gone. I will miss him even more every day until I finally join him. But, like the stars I thought I had lost, he is still there. We come and go, but the stars are always there. When my time comes I look forward to seeing his smile once again.

I will know him because his smile will out shine the sun.




April 13, 2019

Chapter 20 - Losing Frank


Losing Frank


I lost my brother Frank for the last time on March 18th, 2011, after a long fight with cancer. But that's not the only time I lost Frank. I'd lost him a few times in my life. I lost him while he was alive for the last time two years ago. That's the last time I saw or spoke to him. For reasons known only to Frank he decided that he wanted nothing to do with me or most of his family. During the last year he developed cancer... or something like that. I can't really say what kind or how long because the information I have is pretty much hearsay.

Because Frank had shut me out... again. I fell from his good grace for some imagined offense. We hadn't spoke for years. I have no idea why and it isn't really important. Frank shutting me out wasn't a new experience. Falling out of favor is something I'm pretty good at and with Frank it was kind of easy. I'm not sure who was the last to call who... and I'm not saying I've tried much myself. Frank shut me out so seriously it took 2 days for the news of his death to reach me.

Frank was lost to me for much of his lifetime. When he was still a very young man he was involved in a terrible crime that sent him away to prison in a distant state. He spent 20 or more years away from all of us. He was my brother, but he was also a total stranger when he finally came home. The brother I remembered was a classic James Dean, delinquent teenage terror. A rebel that I had wrapped in a childhood fantasy that revered the outlaw persona he came to represent. The brother that came home, a hard-edged man, shaped and educated by the penal system, was someone I was both wary of and welcoming too.

Frank and I, along with my brothers, Buddy and Dave, had a birthday in the same week in September. I started calling us 'The Birthday Boys' when I was a kid. It was a special bond between us. Frank missed many birthdays over the years. When Frank came home the first time, despite his battles with his demons, for a few special years we were again "The Birthday Boys". We traveled together every year to places like Las Vegas or the Bahamas to celebrate the event. They were the best years we got to share together as brothers.

The best moment I ever shared with my brothers was because of Frank and his love of gambling. Frank was a big gambler. Betting on sports or playing cards was something he did with a lot of skill. On our trip to Vegas he got the urge to take a trip in a helicopter to go see the Grand Canyon. When we found out how much it cost, almost $2,000, he didn't bat an eye. 'Alright' he said, 'Go away and don't bother me.' With that he sat down at a blackjack table and went to work. Later, the phone in our room rang at about 3:30AM. It was Frank. "Book the trip, I'm going to get some rest," was all he said.

Early that morning we climbed into a helicopter for a trip that will remain the most memorable birthday in my entire life. We shared a lunch, a birthday cake and a champagne toast on the rim of the Grand Canyon. It truly was a gift from Frank that will last a lifetime for all of us. But it was a high point that only serves to stand in painful contrast to the low that his life would also reach.

Frank had a lot of problems dealing with life once he came home. He wasn't able to play the role of the working man. He took to a life of crime. He was actually very good at it. He made a lot of money. His success lent a false sense of stability and he felt he was doing well for a long time. But it caught up to him, as it does to most all people. He was arrested and went away again for another stretch of years.

Between those times spent in incarceration he suffered bouts of mental illness that resulted in hospitalization. He was suicidal and at times seemed to lose all touch with the world around him. Throughout all those years he was always distant and unreachable. He was hard to get close to and even harder to deal with. He knew people too well and hid himself from anyone who tried to get close... even his family. He considered himself the family patriarch and tried to assume the role of the wise elder. But his judgments were often fostered from a suspicious and distrustful view of people that permeated all his relationships.

One evening I received a call from my sister Maureen. Frank had called her and wasn't acting right. He was talking crazy and she was scared. She feared he was going to try and kill himself. She begged me to go and check on him. My reaction is a great example of just how much I both loved and feared Frank. I went with every intention of doing what I had to do to save Frank. But I did something that one ordinarily wouldn't do when the goal was to save a life. I took a knife with me. I'm still conflicted when I think of it. Frank was crazy and I was scared. In my mind, saving Frank could get me killed.

When I reached the house and rang the bell Frank came to the door in his robe. He welcomed me and seemed rational enough. I began to think Maureen had been worried for no reason, until I looked at his legs. From his feet up they were covered in blood. When he opened his robe I saw that his body had stab wounds and cuts all over his chest and arms. Behind him the apartment was covered in blood that trailed through every room in the house and stained every wall and flat surface.

My brother Dave arrived shortly after. Together we got him to the hospital in time to keep him alive. Dave and I spent the rest of the night on our hands and knees cleaning up his blood. We didn't talk much. But the memory is always accompanied by the screams in my head that I suppressed that night. I took solace in the fact that, after having lost my best friend and my brother Nick to suicide, at least I was able to prevent Frank from the same fate.

As far as Frank's reaction, it was not quite what I expected. In some ways I sensed he resented the intrusion. It left him with a sense of indebtedness. And Frank didn't like owing people. Frank felt everyone was out for themselves. Everyone had a secret agenda as far as Frank was concerned. While generous, he always expected something in return when he did someone a favor. In his mind we would be expecting the same from him. It was a favor that he always was waiting for me to collect on.

Staying in Franks good graces was always a beneficial thing. He had money and the means to help in a lot of ways. But the price of his grace was pretty high and not negotiable. Saying no was something that Frank didn't like to hear and never forgot. Not agreeing with him was looked on as a sign of disrespect. To that end I'm sure Frank felt I disrespected him a lot. I could give everything except false praise. And Frank could give a lot of things, but trust was never one of them.

I knew Frank was going to die, but I didn't know I would never get the chance to see him again before he did. I had lobbied The Birthday Boys to go and pay him a visit last year during our birthday week. Ultimately, for various reasons, it was deemed to be a bad idea. He wouldn't like it. He'd be mad. We wouldn't be welcome. Frank had made it perfectly clear what HE wanted. Stay out of my life. So I left it at that thinking... maybe next year.

Now that option is forever gone. Maybe I should have argued that what we wanted was just as important... maybe more so. Frank may have decided he didn't want me in his life, but I wanted him to know that I didn't feel that way about him. I didn't want to have another sibling die distant and angry. I did tell Frank I loved him... but not often enough I'm sure that he really believed it. Frank was the best example of something I have believed all my life... people come and people go. I saved his life... and in the end he took it away from me.

Our sense of mortality grows more acute with age. I know that the years ahead will take more of us, maybe me, sooner than I think. I don't want to let any more years pass without reaching out to the family I have left. No matter how different the paths we may have taken, it is important to me that they know, I never meant to leave any of them behind. I am grateful for having had them in my life and for the times we have had. I want to make the best of the time we have remaining. I want them to know that I love them as best as I am able.

Dealing with unfinished business is one of the most painful parts of the grieving process. We focus on things we never got to say or that we regretted saying. “If only” becomes a silent wish for so many people after the loss of a loved one. Whenever I remember Frank, my regret will be "I should have..."

I've promised myself that I will reach out and touch my siblings and let them know I care. So that when life takes me from them I will be able to say, without regret... “I did”

Chapter 19 - The End of My Beginning 2

The End of My Beginning 2


Kevin finally succeeded in killing himself on his fifth attempt at suicide. I had been there to prevent him from doing it his first four tries. Actually I was the one who found him close to death the first time he attempted suicide. He came to me after each of the three other failed attempts for help. I took him to the hospital each time to patch his wounds. The wounds healed easily enough but the pain that drove him to inflict them never did.

Unfortunately, on the day he died, I wasn't around to take the knife from his hands. Since the day he first tried killing himself I had made it a point to spend as much time with him as possible. We spent a lot of time together anyway, as best friends do, but I made more of an effort after his first suicide attempt. I thought it would help more to be with him rather than let him be alone. But I didn't get the chance on that fateful day.

In a selfish display of disloyalty, I had decided to do my laundry rather than go hang out as we usually did on a Saturday. We lived a just few blocks apart from each other. The Laundromat was on the way to his apartment. On that day I only had a small load and it wouldn't take long to dry. So, rather than head over to his house and hang around while my load dried I stayed and waited. When it was done I headed home. I had a date that night so I didn't see Kevin that day.

The next morning a friend came over early. He brought the news about Kevin. Kevin was dead. He had stabbed himself in the heart. It took a few tries but he finally succeeded and was found with the knife still in his heart ... still in his hand. He killed himself while I was waiting for my laundry to dry. He died in less time than it took for it to dry.

The blame for his death was all his own. He was determined to end his life. Nothing that I, his family and friends said or did could stop him. He alone was to blame. Yet, for over twenty years, while the blame was all his, I lived with the painful knowledge that it was entirely my fault. That much was obvious. It happened when I was doing my laundry. If I had gone over to his house he would still be alive. I wasn't there when he needed me. He died. It was my fault.

The first time I found him was the worst. Kevin was always an early riser. No matter how late we were up the night before, I could never remember Kevin being in bed past 7am. It's how I knew something was wrong that morning. I had tried to raise him by banging on his door and bedroom windows but got no response. I went down to the basketball court and found his roommate. Together we went back and went to his bedroom. We found him in his bed with the covers pulled up to his chin. His breathing sounded labored but he seemed OK. He just wouldn't respond when I tried to wake him. I pulled the covers off intending to toss some cold water on him. It was the pool of blood that covered his t-shirt and the sheets under him that stopped me.

He lay on his back with one arm by his side and the other bent up and under the pillow next to his head. He looked like someone usually does when sleeping peacefully. I couldn't tell where the blood came from until I moved the arm that was bent. When I moved his arm the blood that had dried to a clot in the crook of his arm cracked open and a spurt of blood shot into the air followed by another. He had slashed his arm deeply. If not for the fortunate fact that he passed out with his arm folded he would have bled to death well before we found him.

We were lucky that day. The ambulance came quickly and he was rushed to the hospital where he spent the next week recovering. He resisted suggestions for counseling and rejected any attempt by myself or his family to talk about what lead to his suicide attempt. As friends we had always talked about everything and anything. We shared those intimate and personal secrets that bind friends to each other for a lifetime. I thought I knew him better than anyone. Never once did he ever express a thought that revealed he had considered suicide. After, we talked about his feelings, my feelings, the pain it caused his family and friends, but they were one sided conversations most of the time. I tried every way I could to reach him but he never opened up. I knew how he felt but never learned why he felt what he did.

He had been my best, my closest friend since grade school. We were inseparable growing up, closer than brothers. We shared a passion for music and basketball. He was the first person I ever allowed to read my songs and poetry. When he told me how good he thought the lyrics were I believed him. He helped me to believe in myself. We formed our first band before we were teens. On weekends and during long lazy summer days we would take the court early in the morning, playing basketball until the night took the light away. At night we would practice the music that would take us on to fame and fortune. Kevin was an incredibly talented guitarist. There was no doubt he was going to be a success.

We shared all the usual experiences that kids go through while growing up together. Like two bookends, we held those memories between us. Special, singular, one-time-only moments that I expected us to relive through tall tales as we left those years behind. In one afternoon all those memories were wrenched away. I lost the chance to remember and share the memories we had created growing up. My youth died along with Kevin. Like him my memories died before they had a chance to grow old.

Kevin's services were excruciatingly painful but I didn't know that until years later when they finally got to me. For a long time I was numb to the hurt. His mother was beyond devastated when he died. She cried inconsolably for days after his death. His mothers' cries filled the church and covered the words of the priest from the start to the end of his funeral mass. I can still feel the anguished pain they voiced 30 years later.

I had never attended a wake until I went to Kevin's. I have never gone further than the lobby on the few wakes I've attended since that day. At the wake his mother had tried climbing in the coffin and pulling Kevin into her arms. I was horrified when I entered the viewing and saw Kevin. The image of his body lying bent with his suit twisted and his hair disheveled is one I can never shake. He lay there as if he had been tossed carelessly into place. I remember thinking it looked more like he was being thrown away rather then buried. Of the thousands of memories I have of him it is always the first picture that comes to mind when I think of him.

Life went on and I went with it. I made new friends that have become important parts of my life since then. But you only have one childhood. If you're lucky you have a best friend to share it with. My new friends have friends like that. I laugh when they describe the adventures of their youth together. But I don't share those kinds of memories with them. They didn't know me then. They didn't know Kevin. It would mean having to explain who Kevin was and what happened. The stories would be an intrusion into those happy memories.

When long-time friends reminisce together their stories often start with words such as "Remember that time we ..." I have a hundred stories about the fun Kevin and I had growing up. I never had the chance to start a story with Kevin using those words. I never will.

I am the only one who remembers those days in the beginning of my life. All the memories, those special feelings that should be bringing me the warmth and comfort we often get when we recall the best times in our lives, are now a source of bittersweet pain. Any smiles that come when I think of Kevin and me are wistful and tinged with longing for a future lost.

People who take their own life are often referred to as "suicide victims". But it isn't true really. Kevin committed suicide; His family, his friends, all the people who loved and cared for him are the real victims of his suicide. Left with lives full of unanswered questions, doubt and pain over what we may have done or what we didn't do; Always holding some small measure of guilt that we were, in some way, responsible.

It took twenty years for me to forgive myself for something that wasn't my fault. I did everything I could to prevent Kevin from killing himself. It was what I didn't do that haunts me still. I didn't go over to his house that day. If only I had he ... it's a thought with so many endings that I can never finish it.

I try to forget what no one else remembers but I can't. Kevin died that day and in a very real way, my life, the life I had thought was ahead of me ... of us, ended as well. Time has muted the pain but it hasn't put an end to it. At times, unexpected and unwelcome, it claws its way to the surface. When it does the hurt feels as abrupt and brutal as it did then. In those moments, instead of dwelling on what was, I dream of what might have been.

Chapter 18 - The End of My Beginnings 1

The End of My Beginnings



My mother died when I was just 21. She died as a result of liver and kidney failure. She had been a serious alcoholic most of her life. Her drinking and the abuse her body suffered because of it had finally taken its toll. She was only 48 but she looked older. It was obvious towards the end. But her alcoholism was something I never consciously noticed growing up.

My mother was the center of the Cannata universe as far as I was concerned. While my father was the authority figure and always had the last word... it was usually a word my mother told him to say. It was watching my mother gently and surreptitiously steer my father into making the decision she had already reached that I first remember thinking; the King might rule the country, but the Queen rules the King.

When my father said no to our request for a couple of bucks to go to the movies, it was my mom who somehow slipped us the money with a finger pressed to her lips cautioning us to not say a word... just go. When my dad didn't feel like taking a ride on weekends, it was my Mon who suddenly would think of a good errand to run and say, "Hey, while we're at it, why not take the kids for an ice cream."

She laid on the couch a lot as we got older, giving orders and generally running the household from her command position. I never thought much of it. She worked as hard as any mother should have to and if she could keep things going while reposed on the couch I thought it only fair. She did get up to take control when there was important stuff but she gave orders from her throne just as easily as a queen.

One of the most lasting memories I have of my mother was sitting next to her watching the TV comedy "F-Troop." Without fail she would laugh as hard as a body could all throughout the show. Every time the cannon took out the watch tower she would be in tears. I thought she was nuts, but I loved seeing her laugh that way. It was where she always watched TV as I grew up.

Unknown to me, her position on the couch wasn't simply one of convenience, it was one of support. I was to learn later how much her illness was sapping her strength. While I had discovered her stash of Vodka, I never imagined that my mother was an alcoholic; Let alone one that was dying from her habit.

I should have known, but it's not something a boy wants to think about when it comes to his mother. She was never abusive. She was never visibly drunk... or appeared the way one thinks of drunks. She never staggered around or looked all dazed and confused. She wasn't prone to going off on incoherent rants or slurring her words. She was just a tired mother who worked very hard at raising her kids. She and her best friend, Mal, would often sit together on weekends or during the week and sip their drinks while passing the time. Highballs and Vodka and tonics never seemed like the deadly threats they proved to be. But it's amazing how little we know at the age where we think we know it all.

I was to understand later it was the reason she always looked pregnant long after the birth of my last baby brother. It was her distended abdomen; the effects of the damage to her liver and kidney that kept her stomach swelled. I used to make fun of her, saying her tummy was always ready just in case a new Cannata decided to start cooking. She always laughed at the jokes. I thought I was wicked clever. She never told me what an ass I was.

We finally moved out of the house on Forbes Street, when I was 19. That was when I knew my life was never going to be the same again. I lived in the new house for a while, never really feeling like it was a place where I belonged. I soon found my own apartment.
I didn't like the new house. Neither did my mother. I still wonder how much of a role the move played in her illness. Before we moved she never complained about being sick... ever. She became obviously sick and was hospitalized for the first time shortly after I moved out of the new home and into my first apartment.

Once it became clear just how sick she truly was it wasn't long before she passed away. It happened so fast that it was almost too soon for me to really grasp what was happening. I knew my mom was sick, but I never realized just how sick. Whether it was because no one told me, or, more likely, because I didn't want to know, the extent of my mother's illness was serious long before I was aware that she was even sick. I was pretty clueless. I had no idea how to help once I understood how bad things were. I would have done anything and given my own life to make her well again.

At least I thought I would.

But then came the day she asked me to help her. It was then that I learned that there was nothing I could do and came to understand just how helpless I truly was.

I had always done anything my mother had asked of me. Saying no just wasn't something to be considered. I would go to the store. Do the laundry. Clean the house or yard. Even lie to my father if she asked. My mother meant the world to me. Something I came to better understand after she passed away. I also came to realize that, no matter how much we love someone, sometimes we can be of no help at all.

Just before my mother died she asked me once again, for the final time, to help her. To help her in a way that she felt only I could do. To my unbearable sorrow and regret, the time when my mother needed my help the most... I failed her.

It wasn't because I couldn't. It was because I wouldn't. She was right when she said she knew I could do what she asked. But instead of doing what she needed of me, I let my mother down and, in doing so, I let her die. She died a painful and uncomfortable, as well as untimely death. By clinging to my hopes, hopes both foolish and unrealistic, I caused her to spend her last days alone; without me, and suffering needlessly.

While I couldn't have prevented her death, the damage to her organs was past treatment, I could have helped ease the pain. But that was the problem. Because of the extensive damage to her liver and kidney, any drugs would have just caused even more harm. Her liver and kidney would have failed if subjected to too much or the wrong kind of medication. Giving her drugs for the pain would only have worsened her illness and destroyed any hope of her recovery. Hope that I was stupid enough to still hold when everyone else knew better.
At the height of her pain she came to me crying and desperate. She pressed a $20 dollar bill into my hand. She whispered close and quietly to me.

"Michael," she said. "I know you can get me something to help me. I'm in pain and I feel like I'm going to die if I don't get something to help! The doctors and your father won't give me anything. Please baby... its terrible how I feel. I know you can get me things. You know what I mean. You have friends. Anything you can find. Please?"

She was asking me to go out and find her some drugs on the street; something that would help her pain. Something we both knew she shouldn't have if there was any hope of helping her getting well. She was asking me to do something that would both ease her pain and speed her death.

I had no idea how to respond. I never lied to my mother unless it was to spare me a smack on the head. When it came to important things and their trust, my parents could always count on my honesty. I didn't know it at the time... but what I told my mother turned out to be the most horrible and dishonest lie I ever uttered.

I told her I would try.

I left the house in a complete state of confusion and angst. Every part of my being wanted to help my mother. It killed me to see her in such pain. But if I were to do what she asked she could very well die from taking what I got for her. I didn't want to see her suffer. But even more, I didn't want her to die... especially by my hands.

I didn't go home to my parent's house that night. In fact I stayed away for 3 days. I was afraid to go home to see her look at me; Ashamed to face her and explain why I didn't help. When I finally went back to my parent's house I found out my mother had been admitted to the hospital again the day before. My Dad didn't call me because it was late. I told him I would go and see her the next day after work. I dreaded seeing her but she would have to forgive me just as sure as I had to face her regardless of how disappointed she might be in me. I would just have to explain to her why I couldn't do it. I knew she would forgive me once I explained.

Unfortunately, I never got the chance.Early the next morning I got a call from my father. My mother had passed away during the night.

I didn't cry. In fact to this day I've never really felt anything more than shame. I don't even remember what I did with the $20. That bothers me immensely. All I do remember is that my mother died waiting for me to keep a promise that I never meant to keep. She died believing a lie I told her. I never got the chance to explain that it was because I loved her... that was why I didn't help her.

I thought I missed my mother when she died. It turns out, at that age; I never had any idea what it meant to really miss someone. I was 21 and much too young to have to deal with the loss of a parent. But now, as I look back, I realize that missing her then was only a start. I have missed her more every year... every day... that has passed since that day so many long years ago. While I've watched my friends deal with the deaths and illness of their elderly patents, I feel both sorrow and envy.

Maybe it was a blessing losing my parents at such a young age. I never had to deal with the failing health of a parent suffering from Alzheimer's or from a long term debilitating disease. I watch my friends go through the loss of their elderly parents and try to comfort them as best I can. But I don't really know how much it hurts.

For many it seems a relief that the right time has come. After watching their once vital and energetic parents slowly slip into the cruel grasp of old age, sapped of their vigor and youth, it can almost seem like a kindness to see them go with dignity and expectation after a long and well lived life. Knowing full well they got all anyone could ask of their time on earth.

I envy them their time together. I wish I could have had as much time with my mother. I wish I could have had the chance to help ease her into old age and get the most out of life. To have helped her get everything she deserved as a reward for having cared so well for such a large family. I'm not sure just how capable I would have been. Perhaps I would have failed them now as well as I did then.

But it sure would have been nice to have the chance to find out.